failure state
Strategic Jenga Play via Graph Based Dynamics Modeling
Puthuveetil, Kavya, Zhang, Xinyi, Yokoyama, Kazuto, Narita, Tetsuya
-- Controlled manipulation of multiple objects whose dynamics are closely linked is a challenging problem within contact-rich manipulation, requiring an understanding of how the movement of one will impact the others. Using the Jenga game as a testbed to explore this problem, we graph-based modeling to tackle two different aspects of the task: 1) block selection and 2) block extraction. For block selection, we construct graphs of the Jenga tower and attempt to classify, based on the tower's structure, whether removing a given block will cause the tower to collapse. For block extraction, we train a dynamics model that predicts how all the blocks in the tower will move at each timestep in an extraction trajectory, which we then use in a sampling-based model predictive control loop to safely pull blocks out of the tower with a general-purpose parallel-jaw gripper . We train and evaluate our methods in simulation, demonstrating promising results towards block selection and block extraction on a challenging set of full-sized Jenga towers, even at advanced stages of the game.
When to Localize? A POMDP Approach
Williams, Troi, Torshizi, Kasra, Tokekar, Pratap
Robots often localize to lower navigational errors and facilitate downstream, high-level tasks. However, a robot may want to selectively localize when localization is costly (such as with resource-constrained robots) or inefficient (for example, submersibles that need to surface), especially when navigating in environments with variable numbers of hazards such as obstacles and shipping lanes. In this study, we propose a method that helps a robot determine ``when to localize'' to 1) minimize such actions and 2) not exceed the probability of failure (such as surfacing within high-traffic shipping lanes). We formulate our method as a Constrained Partially Observable Markov Decision Process and use the Cost-Constrained POMCP solver to plan the robot's actions. The solver simulates failure probabilities to decide if a robot moves to its goal or localizes to prevent failure. We performed numerical experiments with multiple baselines.
Optimizing Risk-averse Human-AI Hybrid Teams
Fuchs, Andrew, Passarella, Andrea, Conti, Marco
We anticipate increased instances of humans and AI systems working together in what we refer to as a hybrid team. The increase in collaboration is expected as AI systems gain proficiency and their adoption becomes more widespread. However, their behavior is not error-free, making hybrid teams a very suitable solution. As such, we consider methods for improving performance for these teams of humans and AI systems. For hybrid teams, we will refer to both the humans and AI systems as agents. To improve team performance over that seen for agents operating individually, we propose a manager which learns, through a standard Reinforcement Learning scheme, how to best delegate, over time, the responsibility of taking a decision to any of the agents. We further guide the manager's learning so they also minimize how many changes in delegation are made resulting from undesirable team behavior. We demonstrate the optimality of our manager's performance in several grid environments which include failure states which terminate an episode and should be avoided. We perform our experiments with teams of agents with varying degrees of acceptable risk, in the form of proximity to a failure state, and measure the manager's ability to make effective delegation decisions with respect to its own risk-based constraints, then compare these to the optimal decisions. Our results show our manager can successfully learn desirable delegations which result in team paths near/exactly optimal with respect to path length and number of delegations.
Hierarchical Framework for Interpretable and Probabilistic Model-Based Safe Reinforcement Learning
Abbas, Ammar N., Chasparis, Georgios C., Kelleher, John D.
The difficulty of identifying the physical model of complex systems has led to exploring methods that do not rely on such complex modeling of the systems. Deep reinforcement learning has been the pioneer for solving this problem without the need for relying on the physical model of complex systems by just interacting with it. However, it uses a black-box learning approach that makes it difficult to be applied within real-world and safety-critical systems without providing explanations of the actions derived by the model. Furthermore, an open research question in deep reinforcement learning is how to focus the policy learning of critical decisions within a sparse domain. This paper proposes a novel approach for the use of deep reinforcement learning in safety-critical systems. It combines the advantages of probabilistic modeling and reinforcement learning with the added benefits of interpretability and works in collaboration and synchronization with conventional decision-making strategies. The BC-SRLA is activated in specific situations which are identified autonomously through the fused information of probabilistic model and reinforcement learning, such as abnormal conditions or when the system is near-to-failure. Further, it is initialized with a baseline policy using policy cloning to allow minimum interactions with the environment to address the challenges associated with using RL in safety-critical industries. The effectiveness of the BC-SRLA is demonstrated through a case study in maintenance applied to turbofan engines, where it shows superior performance to the prior art and other baselines.
Efficient Recovery Learning using Model Predictive Meta-Reasoning
Vats, Shivam, Likhachev, Maxim, Kroemer, Oliver
Operating under real world conditions is challenging due to the possibility of a wide range of failures induced by execution errors and state uncertainty. In relatively benign settings, such failures can be overcome by retrying or executing one of a small number of hand-engineered recovery strategies. By contrast, contact-rich sequential manipulation tasks, like opening doors and assembling furniture, are not amenable to exhaustive hand-engineering. To address this issue, we present a general approach for robustifying manipulation strategies in a sample-efficient manner. Our approach incrementally improves robustness by first discovering the failure modes of the current strategy via exploration in simulation and then learning additional recovery skills to handle these failures. To ensure efficient learning, we propose an online algorithm called Meta-Reasoning for Skill Learning (MetaReSkill) that monitors the progress of all recovery policies during training and allocates training resources to recoveries that are likely to improve the task performance the most. We use our approach to learn recovery skills for door-opening and evaluate them both in simulation and on a real robot with little fine-tuning. Compared to open-loop execution, our experiments show that even a limited amount of recovery learning improves task success substantially from 71% to 92.4% in simulation and from 75% to 90% on a real robot.
PARTNR: Pick and place Ambiguity Resolving by Trustworthy iNteractive leaRning
Luijkx, Jelle, Ajanovic, Zlatan, Ferranti, Laura, Kober, Jens
Several recent works show impressive results in mapping language-based human commands and image scene observations to direct robot executable policies (e.g., pick and place poses). However, these approaches do not consider the uncertainty of the trained policy and simply always execute actions suggested by the current policy as the most probable ones. This makes them vulnerable to domain shift and inefficient in the number of required demonstrations. We extend previous works and present the PARTNR algorithm that can detect ambiguities in the trained policy by analyzing multiple modalities in the pick and place poses using topological analysis. PARTNR employs an adaptive, sensitivity-based, gating function that decides if additional user demonstrations are required. User demonstrations are aggregated to the dataset and used for subsequent training. In this way, the policy can adapt promptly to domain shift and it can minimize the number of required demonstrations for a well-trained policy. The adaptive threshold enables to achieve the user-acceptable level of ambiguity to execute the policy autonomously and in turn, increase the trustworthiness of our system. We demonstrate the performance of PARTNR in a table-top pick and place task.
Hidden Markov Models and their Application for Predicting Failure Events
We show how Markov mixed membership models (MMMM) can be used to predict the degradation of assets. We model the degradation path of individual assets, to predict overall failure rates. Instead of a separate distribution for each hidden state, we use hierarchical mixtures of distributions in the exponential family. In our approach the observation distribution of the states is a finite mixture distribution of a small set of (simpler) distributions shared across all states. Using tied-mixture observation distributions offers several advantages. The mixtures act as a regularization for typically very sparse problems, and they reduce the computational effort for the learning algorithm since there are fewer distributions to be found. Using shared mixtures enables sharing of statistical strength between the Markov states and thus transfer learning. We determine for individual assets the trade-off between the risk of failure and extended operating hours by combining a MMMM with a partially observable Markov decision process (POMDP) to dynamically optimize the policy for when and how to maintain the asset.
Reinforcement Learning of Risk-Constrained Policies in Markov Decision Processes
Brazdil, Tomas, Chatterjee, Krishnendu, Novotny, Petr, Vahala, Jiri
Markov decision processes (MDPs) are the defacto frame-work for sequential decision making in the presence ofstochastic uncertainty. A classical optimization criterion forMDPs is to maximize the expected discounted-sum pay-off, which ignores low probability catastrophic events withhighly negative impact on the system. On the other hand,risk-averse policies require the probability of undesirableevents to be below a given threshold, but they do not accountfor optimization of the expected payoff. We consider MDPswith discounted-sum payoff with failure states which repre-sent catastrophic outcomes. The objective of risk-constrainedplanning is to maximize the expected discounted-sum payoffamong risk-averse policies that ensure the probability to en-counter a failure state is below a desired threshold. Our maincontribution is an efficient risk-constrained planning algo-rithm that combines UCT-like search with a predictor learnedthrough interaction with the MDP (in the style of AlphaZero)and with a risk-constrained action selection via linear pro-gramming. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approachwith experiments on classical MDPs from the literature, in-cluding benchmarks with an order of 10^6 states.
A Learnable Safety Measure
Heim, Steve, von Rohr, Alexander, Trimpe, Sebastian, Badri-Spröwitz, Alexander
Failures are challenging for learning to control physical systems since they risk damage, time-consuming resets, and often provide little gradient information. Adding safety constraints to exploration typically requires a lot of prior knowledge and domain expertise. We present a safety measure which implicitly captures how the system dynamics relate to a set of failure states. Not only can this measure be used as a safety function, but also to directly compute the set of safe state-action pairs. Further, we show a model-free approach to learn this measure by active sampling using Gaussian processes. While safety can only be guaranteed after learning the safety measure, we show that failures can already be greatly reduced by using the estimated measure during learning.
Vulcan: A Monte Carlo Algorithm for Large Chance Constrained MDPs with Risk Bounding Functions
Ayton, Benjamin J, Williams, Brian C
Chance Constrained Markov Decision Processes maximize reward subject to a bounded probability of failure, and have been frequently applied for planning with potentially dangerous outcomes or unknown environments. Solution algorithms have required strong heuristics or have been limited to relatively small problems with up to millions of states, because the optimal action to take from a given state depends on the probability of failure in the rest of the policy, leading to a coupled problem that is difficult to solve. In this paper we examine a generalization of a CCMDP that trades off probability of failure against reward through a functional relationship. We derive a constraint that can be applied to each state history in a policy individually, and which guarantees that the chance constraint will be satisfied. The approach decouples states in the CCMDP, so that large problems can be solved efficiently. We then introduce Vulcan, which uses our constraint in order to apply Monte Carlo Tree Search to CCMDPs. Vulcan can be applied to problems where it is unfeasible to generate the entire state space, and policies must be returned in an anytime manner. We show that Vulcan and its variants run tens to hundreds of times faster than linear programming methods, and over ten times faster than heuristic based methods, all without the need for a heuristic, and returning solutions with a mean suboptimality on the order of a few percent. Finally, we use Vulcan to solve for a chance constrained policy in a CCMDP with over $10^{13}$ states in 3 minutes.